Review of Dead Outlaw on Broadway

Dead Outlaw

Dead Outlaw leaves a lasting impression, weaving together a gripping storyline, remarkable performances, and a fresh approach to Broadway production. This show captures the true story of Elmer McCurdy, leaving audiences entertained, intrigued, and, at times, disturbed.

A Gripping and Unsettling True Story

The storyline of Dead Outlaw pulls you in with the tragic yet fascinating tale of Elmer McCurdy, played skillfully by Andrew Durand. McCurdy’s tale is a mixture of crime and dark twists, but what lingers long after the curtains close is the unsettling account of his posthumous treatment. His body was paraded through carnivals and, shockingly, ended up as a haunted house prop in the 1970s. The show doesn’t shy away from these grim realities, making it a thought-provoking experience.

A Unique Take on Broadway Production

Unlike traditional Broadway shows, the production style of Dead Outlaw sets it apart. The band, led by Jeb Brown, takes center stage, with the actors performing around it or above it rather than directly in front. This innovative staging enhances the raw and intimate feel of the production, freshly engaging the audience.

A Musical Blend That Keeps You Moving

The music is a standout aspect of this show. A perfect mix of country and rockabilly, every song had the audience hopping in their seats. The lively and energetic performances by the band elevate the story, making the music an integral part of the show’s appeal.

Stellar Performances

Andrew Durand delivers a remarkable portrayal of Elmer McCurdy, capturing the complexity of his character with skill and depth. Jeb Brown, as the band leader, adds a layer of energy and charm to the experience. The chemistry between the performers and the unique production style make for an unforgettable performance.

Is it Worth Seeing?

Overall, Dead Outlaw is a show worth seeing. It’s unique, thoughtful, and entertaining, with standout performances and fantastic music. I’d highly recommend it, earning a solid 4 out of 5 stars.


P.S. I was recently told that this show is going out.